FeesSafety
Pluang+
FAQ article

How Do I Assess Mutual Fund Returns?

To assess mutual fund returns and analyse a fund's performance, compare its return with a benchmark that matches the type of instruments the fund invests in. On Pluang, you can see this performance comparison in each fund's prospectus and fund fact sheet, at the bottom of the fund's asset page in the Pluang app. Return, or yield, is the main figure to look at, but it only tells you something when it is set against the right benchmark. For money market funds, the benchmark generally used is bank deposit interest. For fixed income funds, it is a bond index such as INDOBeX, the Indonesia Composite Bond Index (ICBI) or the IBPA Index. For equity funds, it is an Indonesian stock index such as IHSG, IDX30 or LQ45. A fund that has done better than its benchmark has outperformed the market it invests in; one that has done worse has lagged it.

Mutual fund type Benchmark generally used What the comparison tells you
Money market fund Bank deposit interest Whether the fund has earned more than keeping the money in a bank deposit
Fixed income fund A bond index, such as INDOBeX, the Indonesia Composite Bond Index (ICBI) or the IBPA Index Whether the fund has done better than the bond market
Equity fund An Indonesian stock index, such as IHSG, IDX30 or LQ45 Whether the fund has done better than the Indonesian stock market

Tips for a fair comparison:

  • Use the same period: Compare the fund and its benchmark over exactly the same time frame.
  • Look at several periods: A fund that beats its benchmark over several periods is more consistent than one that did well only once.
  • Compare like with like: Compare a fund with other funds of the same type, not an equity fund with a money market fund.
  • Weigh risk as well as return: On Pluang, each fund's asset page also shows 1Y Annualised Volatility, 1Y Sharpe Ratio, Max Drawdown 1Y, AUM and Risk Level.
  • Remember that costs are already inside the NAV: The costs borne by a fund are included in its Net Asset Value (NAV), so NAV-based returns already reflect them.

Related questions:

Q: Where can I see mutual fund returns on Pluang?
Open the fund's asset page in the Pluang app. At the bottom of the page you will find the fund's prospectus and fund fact sheet, which show its performance and how it compares with a benchmark. The asset page itself also shows risk indicators such as 1Y Annualised Volatility, 1Y Sharpe Ratio, Max Drawdown 1Y, AUM and Risk Level, which help you judge how much risk the fund took to earn its return.

Q: How do I calculate mutual fund returns?
A mutual fund's return comes from the change in its NAB per unit: (NAB per unit at the end − NAB per unit at the start) ÷ NAB per unit at the start × 100%. For example, if the NAB per unit rises from Rp1,250 to Rp1,300, the return for that period is 4%. Because a fund's costs are already included in its NAB, a NAB-based return already reflects them. For funds that pay dividends, the extra units from each dividend also add to the value of your investment. For your own position, the fund's asset page on Pluang shows Estimasi Untung Atau Rugi: today's price minus your average purchase price, multiplied by the units you hold.

Q: What do volatility, Sharpe ratio and max drawdown on the asset page mean?
1Y Annualised Volatility shows how much the fund's value has varied over a year: the higher it is, the bigger the swings. The 1Y Sharpe Ratio weighs return against risk, and a higher Sharpe ratio indicates better potential performance for the risk taken. Max Drawdown 1Y is the largest fall from a peak to a low over one year before a new peak was reached, showing the worst loss an investor could have seen.

Q: Why compare mutual fund returns with a benchmark?
Because a return on its own does not tell you whether it is good. A fund's return mostly reflects how its market moved, so the same return can be strong in a falling market and weak in a rising one. Comparing it with a benchmark of the same kind of instruments shows whether the fund's management added value beyond simply following the market it invests in.

Q: Are mutual fund returns guaranteed, and will past returns repeat?
No. Mutual fund returns are not guaranteed, and past performance, including a record of beating the benchmark, does not guarantee future returns. A mutual fund's value can go down as well as up with market conditions and the instruments it holds. Use performance analysis as one input alongside the fund's objective, risk level and costs, and choose funds that fit your own goals and risk tolerance.