Investment
Features
FeesSafety
Academy
More
Pluang+

Compare American Financial Group Inc (AFG) vs Paychex, Inc. (PAYX) Price & Performance

American Financial Group IncTrade
Paychex, Inc.Trade

Price performance (Past 24H)

Key statistics

American Financial Group Inc vs Paychex, Inc. — how do they compare? American Financial Group Inc trades at $144.65 (market cap $11.97B), while Paychex, Inc. trades at $121.38 (market cap $43.14B). The key difference: Paychex, Inc. is far larger — about 3.6× American Financial Group Inc's market cap, and Paychex, Inc. pays the higher dividend (3.92%). Which is the better fit depends on your goals.

AFGPAYX
Market Cap
$11.97B$43.14B
Sector
FinancialsIndustrials
52-Week High
$148.71$140.81
52-Week Low
$124.18$85.57
Enterprise Value
$12.35B$46.63B
Dividend Yield
2.44%3.92%

Aura AI Summary

Signals from Pluang's Aura AI — not financial advice

American Financial Group Inc

American Financial Group (AFG) trades at $144.82, up 0.66% today, with a bullish technical signal from moving averages and a neutral RSI. The company reported strong Q2 2026 earnings of $2.82 per share, beating estimates, driven by property and casualty underwriting and investment income. Revenue for 2025 was $8.12 billion with a net income margin of 10.37%, while 2026 is projected at $8.2 billion with an 11.66% margin. Analysts have a consensus price target of $160.67, with 41% recommending buy.

AFG presents a positive outlook with solid earnings beats and a shareholder-friendly dividend policy, but faces risks from competitive pressures and potential market volatility. The stock's current valuation at a P/E of 12.62 offers room for growth relative to historical averages, supported by institutional interest and consistent cash flow generation.

Paychex, Inc.

Paychex (PAYX) trades at $120.34, down 0.69% on the day, with a bullish technical signal from moving averages but overbought RSI readings. The company shows strong profitability with a 27.03% net income margin and consistent earnings beats, though valuation ratios like a P/E of 24.81 are elevated. Recent news highlights steady small business employment data and product expansion, supporting its core HR services business.

The outlook is mixed: solid fundamentals and dividend payments offer stability, but high valuation and analyst caution (63.33% hold rating) suggest limited near-term upside. Risks include economic sensitivity and debt levels, yet long-term growth in HR outsourcing remains a tailwind for patient investors.

Returns comparison

Trailing returns across standard periods

About American Financial Group Inc

American Financial Group Inc is a holding company that is engaged primarily in property and casualty insurance services. The company has a focus on specialized commercial products for businesses. American also has annuity operations that are focused on sales of traditional fixed and fixed-indexed annuities in the education, bank, and individual markets. American's insurance operations are conducted through the Great American Insurance Group. The group writes business in all 50 of the United States, primarily through independent agents and brokers.

Read more on AFG

About Paychex, Inc.

Paychex is a leading provider of payroll, human capital management, and insurance solutions servicing small and midsize clients primarily in the United States. The company, established in 1979, services over 730,000 clients and pays over 1 in 12 U.S. private-sector workers. Alongside its traditional payroll services, Paychex offers HCM solutions such as benefits administration and time and attendance software, as well as human resources outsourcing and insurance agency services.

Read more on PAYX