CarMax rated 'sell' due to overvaluation, weak growth, and risks from rising Fed rates on auto loans.

CarMax's stock price has risen sharply, driven more by market sentiment than business fundamentals. The company faces challenges including negative revenue growth, weak future guidance, and a high price-to-earnings ratio of 37x, which suggests overvaluation. Additionally, rising Federal Reserve interest rates threaten the affordability of auto loans, potentially pressuring CarMax's margins and retail sales. Wholesale growth is outpacing retail, risking further margin compression as retail stagnates and financing risks increase, leading analysts to rate CarMax as a 'sell.'

CarMax's stock is stable on Pluang, trading at USD 57.21 with no change over the last day. The stock's market cap stands at $8.12 billion as of Sep 21, 2026 18:13 WIB.