Chewy Inc vs Mattel Inc — how do they compare? Chewy Inc trades at $22.62 (market cap $9.20B), while Mattel Inc trades at $15.03 (market cap $4.30B). The key difference: Chewy Inc is far larger — about 2.1× Mattel Inc's market cap. Which is the better fit depends on your goals.
| CHWY | MAT | |
|---|---|---|
Market Cap | $9.20B | $4.30B |
Sector | Consumer Cyclical | Consumer Cyclical |
52-Week High | $42.33 | $22.16 |
52-Week Low | $17.51 | $13.05 |
Enterprise Value | $9.16B | $6.52B |
Signals from Pluang's Aura AI — not financial advice
Chewy (CHWY) trades at $22.59, down 3.99% on the day, reflecting near-term bearish technical pressure. The stock shows strong fundamental progress with revenue climbing to $11.86B in 2025 and net income surging to $392.74M, marking a significant profitability turnaround. Recent earnings beats in Q3 2025 and Q1 2026 contrast with a Q4 2025 miss, indicating volatility. Analyst sentiment remains overwhelmingly positive with an 81.58% buy rating and a $33.82 consensus price target, suggesting substantial upside potential from current levels.
The investment outlook for CHWY is constructive, driven by robust revenue growth, expanding margins, and strong analyst conviction. Key opportunities include the company's dominant position in the pet care e-commerce space and its high customer loyalty through the Autoship subscription model. Primary risks involve competitive pressures from larger retailers, execution challenges in integrating veterinary services, and sensitivity to consumer spending trends. The stock presents a growth opportunity but requires monitoring of quarterly execution against high expectations.
Mattel (MAT) trades at $14.74, down 0.34% today, with a bullish technical signal from moving averages and oversold RSI levels. Recent Q2 2026 earnings missed estimates despite 10% revenue growth, reflecting margin pressure from higher costs. The company maintains solid profitability with a 7.78% net margin and attractive valuation at a P/E of 11.22. Cash flow turned negative in 2025 due to increased financing outflows, though operations remain cash-generative.
Outlook is mixed: analyst consensus leans buy (53%) with a $14 price target, but rising expenses and toy market volatility pose risks. The stock's appeal hinges on execution of its entertainment-driven growth strategy and cost management amid economic headwinds.
Trailing returns across standard periods
Chewy is the largest e-commerce pet care retailer in the U.S., generating $8.9 billion in 2021 sales across pet food, treats, hard goods, and pharmacy categories. The firm was founded in 2011, acquired by PetSmart in 2017, and tapped public markets as a standalone company in 2019, after spending a couple of years developing under the aegis of the pet superstore chain. The firm generates sales from pet food, treats, over-the-counter medications, medical prescription fulfillment, and hard goods, like crates, leashes, and bowls.
Read more on CHWY →Mattel markets toy products that are sold to its wholesale customers and direct to retail consumers. The company offers products for children and families, including toys for infants and preschoolers, girls and boys, youth electronics, handheld and other games, puzzles, educational toys, media-driven products, and plush and fashion-related toys. Mattel's owned portfolio includes Barbie, Hot Wheels, Fisher-Price, Thomas & Friends, and American Girl. In addition, it currently manufactures toy products for its segments both internally and externally (through manufacturing partners). Just over half of its net sales are in North America, while the remainder stem from international markets.
Read more on MAT →