American States Water Company vs Modine Manufacturing Company — how do they compare? American States Water Company trades at $87.53 (market cap $3.43B), while Modine Manufacturing Company trades at $200 (market cap $10.15B). The key difference: Modine Manufacturing Company is far larger — about 3× American States Water Company's market cap, and American States Water Company pays a 2.52% dividend while Modine Manufacturing Company pays none. Which is the better fit depends on your goals.
| AWR | MOD | |
|---|---|---|
Market Cap | $3.43B | $10.15B |
Sector | Utilities | Technology |
52-Week High | $89.28 | $306.89 |
52-Week Low | $70.10 | $119.68 |
Enterprise Value | $4.33B | $10.58B |
Dividend Yield | 2.52% | — |
Signals from Pluang's Aura AI — not financial advice
American States Water (AWR) trades at $87.39, up 2.01% today, with strong technical momentum showing bullish moving averages and support at $86. The company reported Q2 2026 EPS of $1.09, beating estimates by 19.1%, driven by water rate increases and 11.2% revenue growth. AWR maintains exceptional profitability with 20.52% net margins and recently announced an 8.2% dividend increase, extending its 71-year dividend growth streak.
While AWR demonstrates operational excellence and dividend reliability, the stock faces valuation concerns with a P/E of 23.65 above sector averages. Analyst sentiment is mixed with only 20% buy ratings, reflecting concerns about limited upside. Regulatory dependency and high capital expenditures present ongoing risks, though the company's monopoly position and infrastructure investments provide stability.
Modine Manufacturing (MOD) trades at $195.60, up 1.6% on the day, with a bearish technical signal but strong fundamental growth driven by data center demand. The stock shows stretched valuation with a P/E of 71.27, yet has beaten earnings estimates for three consecutive quarters. Recent news highlights surging data center sales but also margin pressure and supply-chain constraints.
Outlook is mixed: robust revenue growth and a $319 consensus price target suggest upside, but high valuation, margin compression, and technical weakness pose risks. Investors should weigh strong analyst buy ratings against execution challenges in a competitive thermal management market.
Trailing returns across standard periods
Latest headlines on both assets
American States Water provides water and electric services to over one million people in the U.S. It also manages water and wastewater systems for various military bases under long-term privatization contracts.
Read more on AWR →Modine Manufacturing Company is a global leader in thermal management technology and solutions. The company engineers, manufactures, and markets heat transfer products for a wide range of applications across the automotive, commercial, industrial, and HVAC (heating, ventilation, and air conditioning) markets. Modine's products include engine cooling systems, heat exchangers, and ventilation systems, providing critical thermal solutions for vehicles, data centers, and various equipment worldwide.
Read more on MOD →