Compare American Financial Group Inc (AFG) vs J M Smucker Co (SJM) Price & Performance
Price performance (Past 24H)
Key statistics
Key statistics
American Financial Group Inc vs J M Smucker Co — how do they compare? American Financial Group Inc trades at $144.65 (market cap $11.97B), while J M Smucker Co trades at $117.46 (market cap $12.54B). The key difference: American Financial Group Inc and J M Smucker Co are close in size by market cap, and J M Smucker Co pays the higher dividend (3.82%). Which is the better fit depends on your goals.
| AFG | SJM | |
|---|---|---|
Market Cap | $11.97B | $12.54B |
Sector | Financials | Consumer Staples |
52-Week High | $148.71 | $126.35 |
52-Week Low | $124.18 | $89.53 |
Enterprise Value | $12.35B | $19.57B |
Dividend Yield | 2.44% | 3.82% |
Aura AI Summary
Signals from Pluang's Aura AI — not financial advice
Aura AI Summary
Signals from Pluang's Aura AI — not financial advice
American Financial Group (AFG) trades at $144.82, up 0.66% today, with a bullish technical signal from moving averages and a neutral RSI. The company reported strong Q2 2026 earnings of $2.82 per share, beating estimates, driven by property and casualty underwriting and investment income. Revenue for 2025 was $8.12 billion with a net income margin of 10.37%, while 2026 is projected at $8.2 billion with an 11.66% margin. Analysts have a consensus price target of $160.67, with 41% recommending buy.
AFG presents a positive outlook with solid earnings beats and a shareholder-friendly dividend policy, but faces risks from competitive pressures and potential market volatility. The stock's current valuation at a P/E of 12.62 offers room for growth relative to historical averages, supported by institutional interest and consistent cash flow generation.
SJM trades at $118.79, up 0.61% today, with a bullish technical signal and analyst consensus price target of $125.11. Recent earnings have shown beats in Q4 2025 and Q1 2026, but the company reported a net loss of $1.23B in 2025, with negative profit margins and ROE. Cash flow from operations remains strong at $1.21B, supporting a dividend increase to $1.12 per share, marking 25 consecutive years of growth. The stock is supported by positive media coverage highlighting value and growth potential.
The outlook is mixed; strong cash flow and dividend growth provide stability, but profitability challenges and high debt levels pose risks. Analyst sentiment is predominantly buy-rated, suggesting upside potential, though investors must weigh fundamental weaknesses against technical and sentiment positives for balanced decision-making.
Returns comparison
Trailing returns across standard periods
Returns comparison
Trailing returns across standard periods
About American Financial Group Inc
American Financial Group Inc is a holding company that is engaged primarily in property and casualty insurance services. The company has a focus on specialized commercial products for businesses. American also has annuity operations that are focused on sales of traditional fixed and fixed-indexed annuities in the education, bank, and individual markets. American's insurance operations are conducted through the Great American Insurance Group. The group writes business in all 50 of the United States, primarily through independent agents and brokers.
Read more on AFG →About J M Smucker Co
J.M. Smucker is a packaged food company that primarily operates in the U.S. retail channel (87% of fiscal 2022 revenue), but also in U.S. food-service (7%), and international (6%). Its largest segment is pet food and treats (36% of 2022 revenue), with popular brands such as Milk-Bone, Meow Mix, 9Lives, Kibbles 'n Bits, Nature's Recipe, and Rachael Ray Nutrish. Its second-largest category is coffee (35% across channels) with the number-two brand Folgers and number-six Dunkin'. Other large categories are peanut butter (10%), with number-one Jif, fruit spreads (5%) with number-one Smucker's, and frozen hand-held foods (6%) with number-one Uncrustables.
Read more on SJM →
