Compare American Financial Group Inc (AFG) vs Ally Financial Inc (ALLY) Price & Performance
Price performance
Price movement over the last 24 hours
Key statistics
Key statistics
American Financial Group Inc vs Ally Financial Inc — how do they compare? American Financial Group Inc trades at $141.21 (market cap $11.86B), while Ally Financial Inc trades at $44.33 (market cap $13.92B). The key difference: Ally Financial Inc is the larger of the two by market cap, and Ally Financial Inc pays the higher dividend (2.64%). Which is the better fit depends on your goals.
| AFG | ALLY | |
|---|---|---|
Market Cap | $11.86B | $13.92B |
Sector | Financials | Financials |
52-Week High | $148.71 | $47.25 |
52-Week Low | $122.42 | $35.96 |
Enterprise Value | $12.33B | — |
Dividend Yield | 2.46% | 2.64% |
Aura AI Summary
Signals from Pluang's Aura AI — not financial advice
Aura AI Summary
Signals from Pluang's Aura AI — not financial advice
AFG trades at $142.80, up 0.04% with a bullish technical outlook. The stock shows strong profitability with 10.84% net margin and 19.38% ROE, though Q1 2026 earnings missed estimates. Recent dividend declarations of $0.88 per share highlight shareholder returns. Analyst consensus is mixed with 41% buy ratings and a $149 price target, representing 4.3% upside from current levels.
AFG offers moderate upside potential with solid fundamentals and consistent dividends, but faces execution risks after recent earnings miss. The insurance sector exposure provides stability, though competitive pressures and regulatory changes remain key watchpoints for investors seeking steady returns with income generation.
Ally Financial (ALLY) trades at $45.40, up 0.18% with strong analyst support (68% buy ratings) and a $54 consensus price target. The stock shows bullish technical momentum with recent earnings beats in Q3 2025-Q1 2026. Fundamentals remain solid with a P/E of 11.22 and net income margin of 14.9%, though revenue has declined from $9.2B in 2022 to $8.77B in 2025. Recent corporate developments include a $0.30 dividend payment and upcoming Q2 2026 earnings release on July 21, 2026.
ALLY presents a compelling value opportunity with attractive valuation metrics and consistent earnings outperformance. The primary investment thesis centers on the company's dominant auto lending position and shareholder returns via dividends. Key risks include revenue stagnation, macroeconomic sensitivity to interest rates, and competitive pressure from digital banking disruptors. Upside potential exists if Q2 2026 earnings meet or exceed the $1.26 EPS estimate.
Returns comparison
Trailing returns across standard periods
Returns comparison
Trailing returns across standard periods
Top news
Latest headlines on both assets
Top news
Latest headlines on both assets
About American Financial Group Inc
American Financial Group Inc is a holding company that is engaged primarily in property and casualty insurance services. The company has a focus on specialized commercial products for businesses. American also has annuity operations that are focused on sales of traditional fixed and fixed-indexed annuities in the education, bank, and individual markets. American's insurance operations are conducted through the Great American Insurance Group. The group writes business in all 50 of the United States, primarily through independent agents and brokers.
Read more on AFG →About Ally Financial Inc
Ally Financial Inc is a diversified financial services firm that services automotive dealers and their retail customers. The company operates as a financial holding company and a bank holding company. Its banking subsidiary, Ally Bank, caters to the direct banking market through Internet, mobile, and mail. The company reports four business segments including Automotive Finance operations, Insurance operations, Mortgage Finance operations and Corporate Finance operations.
Read more on ALLY →
